From the Passenger's Perspective: Winter 2013 4X4 Comparison

In anticipation of the upcoming winter, I decided to do my first comparison test, between a few 4X4s.  Many thanks to Geneva Foreign & Sports in Geneva, NY for letting me in the cars for the test.  Here are the cars and some of the stats:

2006 BMW X3 3.01
AWD Six-Speed Auto
225 HP 3.0L I6
15/23 MPG

2009 Jeep Patriot Limited
4WD Five-Speed Auto
172 HP 2.4L I4
23/28 MPG

2006 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Premium
AWD Five-Speed Manual
173 HP 2.5L Boxer-4
23/28 MPG

2007 Volvo XC70 Wagon
AWD Five-Speed Auto
208 HP 2.5L I5 Turbo
19/26 MPG

So those are the contenders, let's get to it

Looks
None of these cars are what you would call striking on the outside, and of course, that isn't what they are about.  Nonetheless, of the four I think the BMW looks the best, a combo of the kidney grille and the sportier-than-the-rest stance.  The Subaru comes a distant second with the Volvo clinching third, and the Patriot coming in fourth.
On the inside, things are very similar as far as aesthetic appeal. Take note this has nothing to do with the functionality of the interior.  I think the BMW also has the best looking interior, a combination of modern German tech and a nice color arrangement.  The Volvo comes second with a slightly-sleek but still very logical and Swedish design.  The Subaru gets third, with a nice simple metallic feel, though the upholstery looks a bit 1990s.  The Jeep again gets fourth, only because everything seems miles away from where you are sitting.  You'd have to be at least 6' 2" to reach the rear-view mirror.



















Interior Quality
With big 4X4s like these, you expect all of them to be made to withstand abuse and harsh climates.  This segment deals with the quality and functionality of the interiors of the contenders.
I would have expected the X3 to again win the segment, but I am actually going to award first place to the Volvo XC70.  It seemed to be the best interior as far as the way it was screwed together, and the layout was nice and logical.  You could almost hear Spock telling the Volvo engineers what to do. It had everything you would need, and nothing you could do without.
The BMW comes a close second.  It was overall a better place to sit in than the Volvo, but in layout and control functionality, it received some demerits.  The main issue was finding buttons.  It took a few minutes to figure out how to unlock the car, until finding out that the unlock button was where the hazard light button was.
Third and fourth are more difficult.  I liked the simple, utilitarian feel in the Subaru, but the Jeep had more actual things in it.  Overall I'd say the Subaru clinches third just because in the Jeep, you can never find anything because everything is laid out so oddly.










































Driving Dynamics
Again, none of these cars are meant for pure driving feel, but it is still important.  BMW has always been great at making cars handle well, and the X3 is no exception.  It has often been praised for feeling like a car to drive, and that the X3 does.  It takes a little while to get yourself accustomed to the heavy steering (or so I've been told), but when you do, the car feels like it has grip.  The X3 feels solid, and, to an extent, you can feel the road through your fingertips.   The BMW also has the most power, and you can tell.  It sounds the best, too.
In second comes the Volvo. It may not handle as well as the BMW, but it still goes around corners with some confidence.  The steering is perfectly weighted, and the power feels just right.  The five-cylinder turbo in the Volvo doesn't feel as refined as the engine in the BMW, but the turbo kicks in and you get sufficient power to startle the kids in the back.
Again, in third place comes the Forester.  It was the only manual we drove, and the gearbox was just too clunky, and it really strained the engine.  As for the handling, well the Subaru is a box on wheels, so it handles like one.
And in fourth comes the Jeep Patriot.  It lacked in the handling department.  You feel as though you have no control over the front wheels.  However, the engine didn't feel as though it lacked power, it was just too harsh in delivery.

Comfort
Now, these cars are for the school run, so they should be comfortable.  In first place comes the Volvo XC70.  My only problem was the slightly unsupportive seats, but other than that, it was spot on.  The suspension absorbed the bumps, and you could just sink into the interior and feel as though you aren't really in a car.
In second place comes the BMW X3.  It has a slightly sportier suspension set up, so of course it will lose its ride comfort somewhat.  However, the seats were perfect and there was almost no noise.
In third again comes the Subaru Forester.  The ride quality was decent, but the engine noise was a bit much and the seats were a bit itchy.
In fourth again was the Jeep Patriot.  The ride was iffy, it was a bit too bouncy.  The body rolled a ton and the engine made a significant amount of noise.

Spaciousness
The primary purpose of these cars is space, that's why you buy them.  The winner of this category is again the Volvo, which impressed me with its huge trunk space, made twice as large by folding the rear seats down.  Volvo has always been good at spacious wagons, and the XC70 is no exception.
In second is the X3.  Despite it's sporty look it has very spacious rear seat area, and decent trunk space.
In third comes the Jeep Patriot.  It had decent space in the back and the trunk was pretty good as well.. However, it was a bit difficult to get the rear seats down.
The Forester got fourth, only because it is much smaller than the other three.  For its size however, it is very spacious indeed.

Conclusion
In conclusion, all these cars could be justified.  However, overall in first place is the Volvo XC70.  I loved it's logical interior layout, the comfort of it's ride and the incredibly spacious trunk.  Perfect for the mom with some children to ferry to and from school/sports etc.
Second place goes to the BMW X3, with it's excellent interior and great car-like driving experience.  Not so much a journey car, but an epic urban taxi.
Third is the Subaru Forester.  It would be the ideal car for somebody who needs a small, cheap, utilitarian workhorse.
And in fourth is the Jeep Patriot (Again).  However, if you are somebody who just needs a car that should be able to do some off-roading, this is your car.
Those are the standings, but I will say the car I would buy with my own money would be the BMW X3.  It wasn't quite good enough to win the test, but it wins my vote.

Note: All these cars are currently available on www.gfs1.com in Geneva, New York, all for under $18,000.